Monster of the Week: The Siren

John William Waterhouse, The Siren, 1900

The Siren (1900) by John William Waterhouse

Temptation can take many forms, but the fear of being seduced by the song of a siren has haunted mankind for millennia. From a secluded island home, Sirens enthrall passing sailors with their supernatural song. Their voices cast doom on those who hear their call.

Their song, though irresistibly sweet, was no less sad than sweet, and lapped both body and soul in a fatal lethargy, the forerunner of death and corruption.”
-Walter Copland Perry

terracotta Siren, Greece, 300 BCE Photo Peter Horree,Alamy

A terracotta Siren from Greece, 300 BCE. Photo: Peter Horree/Alamy

The ancient Greeks described Sirens as bird-like creatures with human heads. These sea-nymphs live on islands surrounded by cliffs. With their beautiful voices, Sirens are able to lure sailors to their deaths. The siren song entices seamen to sail their ships into the rocky shore. In Roman accounts, Sirens were described as beautiful women who tempted mariners to their flowery shores, where the men languished until death. Modern reports of Sirens are more likely to be of a beautiful woman than a winged creature, but the peril of their song remains the same.

Sirens are skilled musicians, using instruments and voice to entice those who pass their island home. Their singing voices, as well as skill with lyre and flute, give Sirens the means to draw in passing mariners. Additionally, their clever, knavish, and deceitful words persuade men to linger. Sirens tempt the listener with their prophetic wisdom.

Now stop your ship and listen to our voices. All those who pass this way hear honeyed song/Poured from our mouths. The music brings them joy/And they go on their way with greater knowledge.” – The Odyssey, translated by Emily Wilson

These enticements give their victims hope, but the Sirens’ seduction ultimately ends with death and destruction.

Historical Accounts

Sirens were originally the companions of the Greek goddess Persephone. After Hades abducted Persephone, her mother, Demeter, gave handmaidens the bodies of birds in order to assist in the search. When Persephone could not be found, the Sirens eventually settled on the island of Anthemoessa. According to the Roman poets Vigil and Ovid, three rocky islands known as Sirenum scopuli were home to Sirens, who would bewitch passing sailors with their beautiful songs.

Marble sarcophagus with the contest between the Muses and the Sirens

Marble sarcophagus with the contest between the Muses and the Sirens, 3rd century A.D.

Owing to their reputations as captivating singers, the Greek goddess Hera called for a musical contest between the Sirens and the Muses. Zeus had created the Muses to celebrate victory over the Titans and to forget the evils of the world through their joyful song and dance. The Muses inspired the highest intellectual and artistic aspirations in gods and men alike. The destructive Sirens, with voices tainted by death, lost the contest to the graceful Muses. As a mark of humiliation, the Muses plucked the Sirens’ feathers and wore them as victory crowns.

According to The Argonautica, Jason and the men of the Argo sailed past the Sirens on their return journey from finding the Golden Fleece. In response to the danger, Orpheus drew his lyre and played music to drown out their enchanting songs.

In Homer’s Odyssey, Odysseus also had to pass the Sirens on his way home. Circe warns Odysseus that the Sirens call out to sailors from their meadow, a place filled with the rotting bodies of men previously lured to the shore.

First you will come to Sirens, who bewitch everyone who comes near them. If any man draws near in his innocence and listens to their voice, he never sees home again; never again will wife and little children run to greet him with joy; but the Sirens will bewitch him with their melodious song. There in a meadow they sit and all round is a great heap of bones, mouldering bodies and withering skins.”

Odysseus and the Sirens

Ulysses and the Sirens (1891) by John William Waterhouse

In order to make the perilous journey, the sailors must fill their ears with wax to make them immune to the Sirens’ song. But curiosity gets the best of Odysseus, and he orders his men to lash him to the mast of the ship so he can listen to their song without throwing himself into the sea. As the ship passes, the Sirens tempt Odysseus with the promise of knowledge. When offered the opportunity to learn what has occurred at Troy and “all that shall hereafter be upon the fruitful earth,” it’s only his physical restraints that keep Odysseus from steering the ship into the rocks. The Sirens provide a temptation so powerful—the acquisition of hidden knowledge—that Odysseus was willing to risk his own life, and that of his crew.

Siren or Mermaid

Siren - Bestiary Harley

An image of a siren that has both siren and mermaid qualities. Siren, from the Bestiary Harley. Artist unknown.

Some believe that Sirens are the precursor to the Northern European mermaids. Unlike the half-bird creatures of ancient Greece, mermaids are half-woman, half-fish creatures who dwell in the water. Both Sirens and mermaids are known to lure sailors into the sea, but Sirens do so through music, song, and wisdom, while mermaids typically tempt men with their beauty. Mermaids are sometimes referred to as sirens or given the siren characteristic of beautiful singing or luring men to their doom. A recent example of this is the Freeform television series Siren, which features creatures referred to as sirens, but which are actually mermaids with the ability to enchant through song. Of course, the title “Mermaid” wouldn’t resonate with the same drama as “Siren.” Mermaids are often seen to be more compassionate, even loving, towards humanity, while Sirens are characterized as dangerous and wicked.

Examples of Sirens in Popular Culture

Literature

  • Percy Jackson, a young adult series based on Greek mythology, portrays Sirens as giant vulture-like creatures with human heads that change into different people. Though they smile and charm, their faces remain bloody from the remnants of their previous victims.
  • In the Piers Anthony novel The Source of Magic, the protagonists must escape a Siren who can cause men to travel to her location by playing a dulcimer and singing an enchanting song.
  • In The Orphan’s Tales series by Catherynne M. Valente, three sirens sing happily on their rocky island, unaware that their voices cause sailors to jump to their deaths. When they learn of the devastation they have wrought, they leave their island, taking a vow to never sing again.

Poetry

  • The Siren by Edward Armitage, 1888

    The Siren (1888) by Edward Armitage

    In The Divine Comedy, the 14th-century narrative poem, Dante dreams of a siren prior to ascending to the fifth terrace of Purgatory. Under his gaze, she transforms from repulsive to desirable, a metaphor for the ugliness of sin and excessive love. When Virgil reveals her true nature, Dante is released from her spell.

  • The 1824 poem Die Lorelei describes a siren sitting atop a cliff that overlooks the Rhine combing her hair. Her beauty and song lures skippers to their deaths on the dangerous rocks below.

Film

  • In the film O Brother, Where Art Thou? (2000), an adaptation of The Odyssey, the protagonists come upon three women singing and doing wash in a river who appear to be Sirens. When they wake from a drug-induced sleep, one of the men has seemingly transformed into a frog.
  • In the horror movie Siren (2010), some friends on a sail are lured to an island inhabited by a siren.
  • Sirens are featured in Ice Age 4: Continental Drift (2012) as giant prehistoric lungfish with the ability to enchant.

Television

  • Iris

    Iris, a Siren from Isekai Shokudou (Restaurant to Another World),

    In season 4 of Supernatural, Sam and Dean investigate a Siren compelling men to murder their wives. In Supernatural lore, sirens want those they enthrall to kill others as a show of devotion. Once under its spell, the Siren pits Sam and Dean against each other in a fight to the death for its love.

  • In Lost Girl, sirens are a Light Fae species able to placate, control, banish, kill, heal, and alleviate pain through song. The character Hale, who appeared in the first four seasons of the series, is a Siren from a noble family.
  • In the 1960s series Batman, actress Joan Collins played Lorelei Circe, AKA The Siren. She was able to put any man under her control by singing a note three octaves above high C.
  • Red Dwarf featured a space version of shapeshifting sirens known as Psirens. The Psirens lure spaceship crew in order to feast on their brains.
  • The Simpsons created an adaptation of The Odyssey in which Homer was lured to the Island of the Sirens, only to find that the sirens in question were Marge’s sisters Patty and Selma.
  • Isekai Shokudou (Restaurant to Another World), an anime series, features restaurant guests Arius and Iris, a pair of juvenile Sirens from the Continental Sea. Arius and Iris are able to enthrall others with their enthusiastic singing.

Games

  • Pathfinder features Sirens that are human-sized female hawks, owls, or eagles with the faces of beautiful women with captivating singing voices that can hypnotize listeners.
  • In Magic: The Gathering, Sirens are a monster race with bird wings, breasts, and legs. They have hypnotic voices, but not all are beautiful. They collect bones, jewels, and other objects, and feed on shipwrecked humans.
  • Black & White 2 has a Siren wonder that turns everyone in its radius into willing followers.
  • Sirens appear in the Final Fantasy series, usually as a summon causing a status ailment.

Podcast

  • In the podcast Hello from the Magic Tavern, Arnie, Chunt, and Usidore interview a Siren from the magical land of Foon.
Viktor Vasnetsov. Sirin (right) and Alkonost (left) Birds of Joy and Sorrow (1896)

A Russian Sirin (right) and Alkonost (left). Birds of Joy and Sorrow (1896) by Viktor Vasnetsov.

Just as Eve took the apple and Pandora opened the box, releasing evil into the world, Sirens embody temptation and betrayal. An affront to reason and moderation, the Siren causes man to act against his better judgment, which leads to his fall. Sirens create the potential for seduction and destruction. The enchanting beauty of the Siren’s song has led many a man to surrender his rationality, and, in turn, his life.

One thought on “Monster of the Week: The Siren

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s