Claire finds Randy being held by the loan shark Salinger

Sam and Dean sort of being jerks

Seriously Gerald, no one care.

The Mark of Cain gives Dean dreams of demon days past

Cas’s tips to treat a bedbug infestation: “You should sleep tight and not let them bite.”

Castiel uses his angel powers to save Claire

Pau Hana at the Tahitian Chief

Bloodbaths compelled by the Mark of Cain are not new for Dean

Being touched by an angel did nothing but bring pain to the life of Claire Novak

Hey Dustin – watch out for all those tall guys standing outside of Weiner Hut

Dean what have you done?!

Randy manipulating Claire’s need for family so he can support his gambling habit

There’s nothing quite like The Three Stooges and a grilled cheese sandwich

Off to a rocky start: Dean: Whoa. Hey, Miley Cyrus, settle. Claire: Eat me, Hasselhoff. Claire, hold on a second. Sam: Look, my name’s — Sam. And you’re Dean. Claire: We’ve met, remember?

Being touched by an angel did nothing but bring pain to the life of Claire Novak

Cas has very limited knowledge of teenage girls with juvenile police records

Rowena tells her cellmate that she is imprisoned for being a horrible mother

Crowley has left his witch mother Rowena locked in a cell for weeks

Dean confirms that ketchup is indeed a vegetable

Crowley has left his witch mother Rowena locked in a cell for weeks

The Mark of Cain emerges in a bloodbath

“Coming?”

Crowley’s mom wants to apologize. Will Crowley fall for it?

Sam what did I do?

Read full recap of “The Things We Left Behind” here.

For more recaps, photos, and news about Supernatural and other shows like iZombie, Constantine, Doctor Who, Game of Thrones, and The Walking Dead, subscribe to receive notification of new spooky content by email. Or you can follow us on Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, Instagram and Google+. Check out our Monsters of the Week and other scary and supernatural posts.